• About

  • Start Today

  • "Can Dr. D Help Me?"

  • Health Articles

  • Resources

  • More

    Social Media

    Infinity Holistic Healthcare

    Chapel Hill, NC 27514

    Driving Directions
    • Instagram
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
    • Google Plus

    Start Today!

    Learn More

    I Didn't Eat for 72 Hours. Here's How it Went.

    December 6, 2019

    I'm Over Overwhelm

    November 12, 2019

    DIY Fasting Mimicking Diet: First Attempt

    June 12, 2019

    Fasting Mimicking Diet: My Experience

    May 3, 2019

    "I Want My Body Back"

    April 2, 2019

    Probiotics and SIBO: Mythology and Reality

    March 18, 2019

    Irritable Bowel Syndrome: What's in a Name?

    March 13, 2019

    Steroids. Symbiosis. Sinuses.

    February 15, 2019

    Tolerating Food Again

    February 6, 2019

    SIBO: It's Really Weird if You Think About it

    November 25, 2018

    Please reload

    Recent Posts

    All About Food Sensitivities

    October 14, 2016

    How to Find a Functional Medicine Doctor Near You

    May 14, 2016

    Finish Your Bridges

    September 20, 2017

    1/3
    Please reload

    Featured Posts
    Nutrition
    Food Sensitivity
    Elimination Diet
    Gluten Sensitivity

    Why I Don't Recommend ALCAT or MRT Testing

    October 19, 2018

    |

    Dr. Nicole DiNezza. DC, NTP

    ALCAT and MRT: You either love 'em or you hate 'em. In this post I will explain why I'm generally in the later camp.

    ALCAT and MRT work via the same principle: Put an immune cell (Leukocyte/white blood cell) on a dish, expose it to antigens (foods), and watch to see if the cell swells or shrivels up. These two tests use different methods to observe this reaction, but they are similar enough that I will cover both.

     

    The big "selling point" for these tests

    There are many blogs, YouTube videos, and clinicians on the internet singing the praises of these two tests, and it all boils down to one main selling point. Proponents of these tests point out that there are multiple pathways (triggering mechanisms) for food to activate an immune response (IgG, IgM, amines) but their presence does not necessarily mean that an immune reaction will happen. Instead of measuring the triggering chemicals (for example, IgG), these tests aim to assess the end result: immune responsiveness to a food.

     

    The single biggest problem with ALCAT and MRT testing, simply put:

    When in your life will you ever expose your immune system to an antigen this way (aside from vaccines)? Food particles normally go through many, many processes and steps before they come into contact with your immune system. How can we expect tests that bypasses the entire normal digestive process and antigen presentation process to reliably test for immune reactivity against food? In short, we cannot.

     

    This is seen in the picture I drew below, but I'll summarize it in text, too. Normally food antigens have to pass through the following steps before provoking an immune response. Please note, allergies, histamine reactions, and food intolerances are different and provoke a different kind of reaction (more here).

     

    Steps between food and your immune system:

    1. Chewing and salivary enzymes

    2. Stomach acid (very acidic)

    3. Digestive enzymes and bicarbonate (basic)

    4. More enzymes

    5. Brush border enzymes

    6. Bacteria, yeast, parasites, viruses in the gut

    7. Microbial metabolites and toxins

    8. Changes in pH from microbial metabolites

    9. Interaction between nutrients in the food and antigens? Or between multiple antigens? Fiber and antigens?

    10. Mucous and antibodies

    11. Absorption by gut epithelial cells

    12. "Sampling" of antigens by dendritic cells (DCs)

    13. "Antigen presentation" by DCs to other cells (T or B cells)

    14. WBC movement into the blood and lymph

    15. Interaction of multiple immune cells (ex: production of antibodies by plasma cells, binding of antibodies to mast cells, histamine binding to mast cells and TH2 cells...)

     

    Another problem with MRT and ALCAT Testing:

     

    Both tests evaluate changes on leukocytes "including monocytes, lymphocytes, eosinophils, basophils, and neutrophils." Holy macaroni, is that broad! These five types of cells differ widely in their behavior and skills. Even within each category, there are many different types of cells (ex: lymphocytes = T cells, B cells, NK cells) that do very different things.

     

    How can you predict what is "normal" and "abnormal" for a test when you're comparing apples to zucchini? In my opinion, you cannot. For example if you test the gluten antigen against 10 different samples, but you're using a different type of white blood cell every time, how can you possibly standardize the results? Can we really expect the same reaction from all of the troops in such a diverse army?

    Unfortunately, there isn't a perfect test for food sensitivities. I think Cyrex is the closest, for those who want a test to guide them, but that's all it is- a guide. The ultimate challenge is to eliminate a food for a few months and reintroduce it.

     

    Wishing you a diverse and healthy diet,

     

     

    Tags:

    Food Sensitivity

    Elimination Diet

    Please reload

    Follow Us

    23 and Me

    AIP

    Acid

    Acid Reflux

    Allergy

    Amazon

    Autoimmune

    Brain Fog

    Buyer beware

    Casein

    Celiac Disease

    Dairy

    Detox

    Diet

    Digestion

    Elimination Diet

    Epstein Barr

    FMD

    FODMAPs